Skip to content
where news meets its scholarly match
  • Newsletters
  • Arts & Culture
    • Art & Art History
    • Film & Media
    • Language & Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Business & Economics
    • Business
    • Economics
  • Politics & History
    • Politics & Government
    • U.S. History
    • World History
    • Social History
    • Quirky History
  • Science & Technology
    • Health
    • Natural Science
    • Plants & Animals
    • Sustainability & The Environment
    • Technology
  • Education & Society
    • Education
    • Lifestyle
    • Religion
    • Social Sciences
  • About JSTOR Daily
  • Newsletters
  • Contact The Editors
  • Support JSTOR Daily
Politics & History

Is Scotland a Nation?

What is Scotland, a country and/or nation, or just a region within Great Britain, a piece of the United Kingdom? Let’s explore Scots nationalism.

1596 Mercator map of Scotland
A 1596 Mercator map of Scotland
via Wikimedia Commons/Library of Congress
By: Matthew Wills
March 29, 2017 August 17, 2018
2 minutes
Share Tweet Email Print

In 1997, 74% of voters in Scotland voted to re-establish a Scottish Parliament after three centuries. But then, in 2014, 55% of Scots said no to being an independent country. And then, in last year’s Brexit referendum, 62% voted to remain in the European Union, putting Scotland (and Northern Ireland) at odds with England and Wales, the other parts of the United Kingdom, who voted to leave. Now, as the UK wrestles with Brexit, the Scottish First Minister has called for a new independence referendum.

Nationalism often turns out to be a creation of specific circumstances in the not so ancient past. Some have argued that Scots nationalism is such a creation, a cultural resurgence after the defeat of the Jacobites at Culloden in 1746. “Jacobites” comes from the Latin version of “James”: followers of the heirs of King James II, known as James VII in Scotland. He was Catholic deposed by English Protestants with help of the Dutch in the Glorious Revolution of 1688. The disarmament and suppression of Scotland, especially in the Highlands, that followed Culloden included banning the wearing of traditional tartan. Scots nationalism was born out of the bitter experience of this suppression, at least in the usual histories.

Scots become Scots in opposition to others.

But Kristen Post Walton delves back to the 1200s to examine the vexing issue of what nationalism is, specifically in the case of Scotland.

“Nationalist ideology can take many forms, from ethnic to linguistic and from cultural to political,” Walton writes, narrowing down the definition of nationalism to “the establishment of a uniqueness which allows members of a state to identify with one another and share a bond or a consciousness, through cultural, political, religious, ethnic, or linguistic similarities which are not shared outside the group.”

“Scottish nationalism was neither fully ethnic nor fully religious” says Walton. She notes the tradition of several languages (Gaelic, English, French, Norse, and Latin) and a population made up of Gaels, Picts, Vikings, Normans, and English (themselves a mixture). But Scots nationalism became defined as oppositional. The southern border with England meant Anglo-Scottish conflict through the early medieval period on. And the surrounding seas bought Scandinavian incursions. Scots become Scots in opposition to others.

English attempts to control their northern neighbors were the stones Scots nationalism sharpened itself on. And as Walton details, the pro-Scots propaganda of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries was poetry, as it would be in the eighteenth century as well. Yet wars for independence against the “auld enemie” got confusing in 1603, when the Scottish King, James VI, went south as James I, inheriting the throne from the childless Elizabeth I. A little over a century later, the Acts of Union cemented north and south together. Are we witnessing the end of that cementing, that auld union, and what does that mean?

Walton ends quoting Robert Burns’s “Farewell even to the Scottish name”—which of course wasn’t the end of the Scottish name—while noting that his words “helped to preserve the idea of Scotland that had been created long before” he was born.

Share Tweet Email Print
Have a correction or comment about this article?
Please contact us.
EnglandnationalismScotlandUnited KingdomInternational Social Science Review
JSTOR logo

Resources

JSTOR is a digital library for scholars, researchers, and students. JSTOR Daily readers can access the original research behind our articles for free on JSTOR.

SCOTTISH NATIONALISM BEFORE 1789: AN IDEOLOGY, A SENTIMENT, OR A CREATION?
By: KRISTEN POST WALTON
International Social Science Review, Vol. 81, No. 3/4 (2006), pp. 111-134
Pi Gamma Mu, International Honor Society in Social Sciences

Join Our Newsletter

    Get your fix of JSTOR Daily’s best stories in your inbox each Thursday.

    Privacy Policy   Contact Us

    You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message.

    Read this next

    Aurora Alaska
    Politics & History

    Buying Alaska

    It's the 150th anniversary of the Alaska Purchase. Why did the Americans want all that ice and why were the Russians willing to sell?

    Trending Posts

    1. The Physics of Karate
    2. Slavery in a Free State: The Case of California
    3. The Punk Rock Linguistics of Cottagecore
    4. Herbs & Verbs: How to Do Witchcraft for Real
    5. The Devastation of Black Wall Street

    More Stories

    Photograph: Marchers carrying a banner with the words 'Visibly Lesbian'

Source: Steve Eason/Getty
    U.S. History

    How NOW Started Standing Up for Lesbians

    If it had been up to national leaders alone, it might have taken much longer.
    Photograph: Gloria Reynolds, a shop assistant in London's King's Road. 

Source: Graham Wood/Getty
    Social History

    Why Black Women Activists Started Wearing Denim

    Members of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee adopted denim clothing for activist work. This had special significance for Black women.
    A man watches the CNN broadcast of the Osama bin Laden tape December 13, 2001 in a New York City store after it was released by the Pentagon.
    U.S. History

    How the Media Can Define Terrorism

    Two scholars argue that the language used to describe violent events influences whether people see it as terrorism—with real-world consequences.
    Social History

    Celebrating Women’s History Month

    Celebrate Women's History Month all March with JSTOR Daily. We hope you'll find the stories below, and the scholarship they include in full, a valuable resource for classroom or leisure reading.

    Recent Posts

    1. How NOW Started Standing Up for Lesbians
    2. The Problem with Unpaid Conservation Work
    3. Extreme Cold and Public Opinion on Climate Change
    4. Why Black Women Activists Started Wearing Denim
    5. Preserving the History of Coronavirus in Queens

    Support JSTOR Daily

    Help us keep publishing stories that provide scholarly context to the news.
    Become a member

    JSTOR Daily provides context for current events using scholarship found in JSTOR, a digital library of academic journals, books, and other material. We publish articles grounded in peer-reviewed research and provide free access to that research for all of our readers.

    • Contact The Editors
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Masthead
    • Newsletters
    • About Us
    • RSS
    • Support JSTOR Daily
    • JSTOR.org
    • Terms and Conditions of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Accessibility
    logo

    JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization helping the academic community use digital technologies to preserve the scholarly record and to advance research and teaching in sustainable ways.

    © ITHAKA. All Rights Reserved. JSTOR®, the JSTOR logo, and ITHAKA® are registered trademarks of ITHAKA.

    Sign up for our weekly newsletter

      Get your fix of JSTOR Daily’s best stories in your inbox each Thursday.

      Privacy Policy   Contact Us

      You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message.