Skip to content
where news meets its scholarly match
  • Newsletters
  • About JSTOR Daily
  • Teaching with Reveal Digital’s American Prison Newspapers Collection
  • Newsletters
  • Arts & Culture
    • Art & Art History
    • Film & Media
    • Language & Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Business & Economics
    • Business
    • Economics
  • Politics & History
    • Politics & Government
    • U.S. History
    • World History
    • Social History
    • Quirky History
  • Science & Technology
    • Health
    • Natural Science
    • Plants & Animals
    • Sustainability & The Environment
    • Technology
  • Education & Society
    • Education
    • Lifestyle
    • Religion
    • Social Sciences
  • Reading Lists
  • Syllabi
  • Columns
  • Open Community Collections on JSTOR
  • Contact The Editors
  • Support JSTOR Daily
Education & Society

When Science and Religion Were Connected

During the Second Great Awakening of 1830, science and religion were seen as “two aspects of the same universal truth.”

methodist religious revival
Engraving of a Methodist camp meeting, 1819.
via Library of Congress
By: Livia Gershon
September 4, 2018 August 31, 2018
3 minutes
Share Tweet Email Print

The contrast between the cold logic of science and the emotionality of religion is a seemingly unshakable binary today. But back in the early nineteenth century, people saw things very differently. Historian Jeffrey A. Mullins examines the religious revivals of the Second Great Awakening in the 1830s.

At that time, Mullins writes, Americans did not see science and religion as opposites. Instead, they were “two aspects of the same universal truth.” And that truth was not based in pure logic. Emotions were a key to human behavior, and controlling and channeling emotions was a job for scientifically- and morally-grounded experts.

This perspective led to a wealth of reformist interventions, from Sunday schools to penitentiaries to graham crackers. Preachers who led religious revivals around the country in the 1830s saw the need for a highly engineered emotional experience.

Religious leaders like prominent Presbyterian minister Charles Grandison Finney travelled from state to state, holding multi-day revivals featuring nighttime preaching, sermons that called on the audience to scrutinize their own sins, and a constant drumbeat of prayer and religious discussion. The events were carefully planned for maximum emotional impact, and they were highly successful, reliably resulting in multiple conversions.

Days and nights of energetic preaching and prayer wore people’s defenses down and excited their “animal passions.”

Many fellow Protestants complained about the formulaic psychological methods, or saw the revivalists as focusing too much on human agency rather than leaving conversions in God’s hands. Universalist Reverend Hosea Faxon Ballou, for example, criticized one revival for its “management and contrivance” by “erring mortals.”

Ballou argued that feelings of grace induced by a premeditated scheme were illegitimate. Days and nights of energetic preaching and prayer simply wore people’s defenses down and excited their “animal passions.”

Want more stories like this one?


    Get your fix of JSTOR Daily’s best stories in your inbox each Thursday.


    Privacy Policy   Contact Us
    You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message.

    But, to Finney and his colleagues, there was nothing wrong with a mechanistic system that prepared souls for conversion. Finney drew on agricultural metaphors to make the case for a scientific approach to spiritual matters. Just like a farmer using agricultural knowledge to cultivate grain, preachers could harness the “laws of nature” to predictably induce a religious awakening among a group.

    Imagine, he wrote, preaching to farmers

    that God is sovereign, and will give them a crop only when it pleases him, and that for them to plow and plant and labor as if they expected to raise a crop is very wrong… and that there is no connection between the means and the result on which they can depend…. Why, they would starve the world to death.

    Revivalists also challenged more conventional Christian reformers’ focus on gradual self-improvement as the road toward salvation and moral behavior. “Shedding the need for prolonged preparation, revivals reinvigorated the idea that all souls were equal before God, and thus had equal capacity to accept his grace,” Mullins writes. And, the preachers argued, having opened to this grace during a revival, newly reborn Christians would gain the “knowledge and perspective as well as the strength to will against sinful choices.”

    Emotions, elicited through a scientifically planned process, were the catalyst for true religious belief.

    Share Tweet Email Print
    Have a correction or comment about this article?
    Please contact us.
    Christianitynineteenth centuryInternational Social Science Review
    JSTOR logo

    Resources

    JSTOR is a digital library for scholars, researchers, and students. JSTOR Daily readers can access the original research behind our articles for free on JSTOR.

    "FITTED TO RECEIVE THE WORD OF GOD": EMOTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC NATURALISM IN THE RELIGIOUS REVIVALS OF THE 1830s
    By: JEFFREY A. MULLINS
    International Social Science Review, Vol. 81, No. 1/2 (2006), pp. 3-15
    Pi Gamma Mu, International Honor Society in Social Sciences

    Join Our Newsletter


      Get your fix of JSTOR Daily’s best stories in your inbox each Thursday.


      Privacy Policy   Contact Us
      You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message.

      Read this next

      anti-abolitionist cartoon
      Education & Society

      How Antebellum Christians Justified Slavery

      After Emancipation, some Southern Protestants refused to revise their proslavery views. In their minds, slavery had been divinely sanctioned.

      Trending Posts

      1. Mindful March: The Unexpected Benefits of Mindfulness
      2. Celebrate World Bear Day!
      3. Girls Gone Greek
      4. Was She Really Rosie?
      5. Why Does the Bible Forbid Tattoos?

      More Stories

      Digital illustration of surrealistic faceless human with spiritual thoughts. Made with vector vibrant color gradient geometry forms. Minimalist textured painting on mental, medical and artistic theme.

      Mindful March: The Unexpected Benefits of Mindfulness

      Mindfulness has been linked with ethical decision making and avoidance of cognitive biases. Can it lead to better performance at work?
      Lifestyle

      The Sweet Sixteen of Sneakers on JSTOR

      Why should basketball fans have all the March Madness fun? We're running a basketball sneaker bracket. Play along on Twitter.
      Religion

      Railroad Chapel Cars Brought God to the People

      Between 1890 and 1946, thirteen railroad chapel cars made their way across America, spreading a Christian message in rural communities.
      Friedrich Nietzsche by Edvard Munch

      The European MonEUlith: Nietzsche and Nationalism

      What can Nietzche’s geophilosophical modes of thought offer us for understanding globalization in his time and pan-European politics today?

      Recent Posts

      1. Plant of the Month: London Rocket
      2. Dummy Boards: the Fun Figures of the 1600s
      3. What it Sounds Like When Doves Cry
      4. Luna Park and the Amusement Park Boom
      5. Ousmane Sembène: Feminism in African Francophone Cinema

      Support JSTOR Daily

      Help us keep publishing stories that provide scholarly context to the news.
      Become a member

      About Us

      JSTOR Daily provides context for current events using scholarship found in JSTOR, a digital library of academic journals, books, and other material. We publish articles grounded in peer-reviewed research and provide free access to that research for all of our readers.

      • Contact The Editors
      • Masthead
      • Newsletters
      • About JSTOR Daily
      • Submission Guidelines
      • RSS
      • About the American Prison Newspapers Collection
      • Submissions: American Prison Newspapers Collection
      • Support JSTOR Daily
      • JSTOR.org
      • Terms and Conditions of Use
      • Privacy Policy
      • Cookie Policy
      • Cookie Settings
      • Accessibility
      logo

      JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization helping the academic community use digital technologies to preserve the scholarly record and to advance research and teaching in sustainable ways.

      © ITHAKA. All Rights Reserved. JSTOR®, the JSTOR logo, and ITHAKA® are registered trademarks of ITHAKA.

      Sign up for our weekly newsletter


        Get your fix of JSTOR Daily’s best stories in your inbox each Thursday.


        Privacy Policy   Contact Us
        You may unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the provided link on any marketing message.