The icon indicates free access to the linked research on JSTOR.

Jews worldwide will soon observe Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, and Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement. But on what evenings will those holidays begin?

JSTOR Daily Membership AdJSTOR Daily Membership Ad

Much of the world lives—or at least conducts business—according to the Gregorian calendar, which was introduced by Pope Gregory XIII in 1582 as a “corrective” to the Julian calendar. But the Jewish (Hebrew) calendar sets the dates for the High Holy Days. As physicists Solomon Gartenhaus and Arnold Tubis explain, while the annual arc of the Jewish calendar runs parallel to that of the Gregorian (the four seasons, determined by Earth’s position relative to the Sun, begin on the the same date in both calendars, for instance), the Jewish calendar is also synchronized in a unique manner with the lunar cycle.

Adding another layer of complexity are externally imposed theological constraints. For instance, regardless of the date according to the relative positions of Moon, Sun, and Earth, the first day of the new year (1 Tishri) can only fall on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, or Saturday.

As Gartenhaus and Tubis point out, designing a calendar that faithfully reconciles solar and the lunar cycles while addressing theological restrictions seems at first glance to be a very formidable—if not impossible—task. They offer at least eight points that need to be addressed for such a calendar to work. To wit:

  1. The solar (tropical) year consists of 365.2422 days.

  2. The lunar cycle consists of 29.53059 days.

  3. The calendar year must consist of an integral number of days.

  4. There is a calendar unit of the month, whose length on the average must be the same as that of a lunar cycle and which at the same time must consist of an integral number of days.

  5. The calendar year must consist of an integral number of months.

  6. There is the calendar unit of the week consisting of exactly seven days, Sunday…Saturday. There is no requirement for a year or a month having an integral number of weeks.

  7. The first day of Rosh Hashanah, the first of Tishri, cannot be on a Sunday, Wednesday, or Friday. […]

  8. A month can only have 29 or 30 days. In particular, months of length 31 days are not permitted.

Impossible, right? But they remind us that there’s “a curious relationship” that helps: the number of days in nineteen solar years equals the number of days in 235 lunar cycles. It’s this nineteen-year period that governs the larger arc of the Jewish calendar.

The accounting isn’t perfect, however. To make the numbers add up properly, “the individual years in each such cycle are divided into one of two types: 12 ordinary years each of 12 months and the remainder of 7 leap years each consisting of 13 months.”

In other words, to reconcile the differences between the solar and lunar calendars, out of every nineteen years, seven need to be leap years with an extra (thirteenth) month of thirty days.

Although derived in part from the ancient Babylonian calendar, this version of the calendar is a relatively new construction. A group of three Jewish leaders, the “Calendar Council,” created the now fixed calendar around 350 CE, or 4110 in the Jewish system. (To determine the year of the Jewish calendar, add 3,760 to the year of the Gregorian calendar if before 1 Tishri; add 3,761 if after 1 Tishri. The current year is 5782.)

Gartenhaus and Tubis explain that one of the main objectives of the Calendar Council was to ensure that the first day of each month aligned with the new Moon, keeping the seasons in step with the lunar cycle over long periods. The Council waited to hear from witnesses as to when a new Moon was spotted.

“The Council would interrogate these witnesses, and if it were confirmed that they had indeed seen a growing crescent moon, for example, and not a waning one and so forth, the 30th day of the given month would then become the first day of the new month,” they write. The council thus fine-tuned the calendar, adjusting the number of days in each month from twenty-nine to thirty and back again to match the new Moon’s arrival.

“In this ad hoc way, it was possible for the months of the year to remain faithful to the lunar cycle while at the same time satisfying the second requirement, of consistency with the seasons.”

Over centuries, the Jewish calendar has been regularized; an ordinary year has twelve months; the leaps years have thirteen, each with a predictable number of days. Whether a leap year or not, the new year (1 Tishri, Rosh Hashanah) begins on the day the new Moon appears. But remember those theological restrictions mentioned above? Since Rosh Hashanah must fall on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, or Saturday, the formal beginning of the new year must wait a day, or even two, for recognition if the new Moon appears on the wrong day of the week.

Support JSTOR Daily! Join our new membership program on Patreon today.


JSTOR is a digital library for scholars, researchers, and students. JSTOR Daily readers can access the original research behind our articles for free on JSTOR.

Shofar, Vol. 25, No. 2 (Winter 2007), pp. 104–124
Purdue University Press